Despite never living more than a six-hour drive from the border, I’d never been to Canada before. Despite being a music journalist for almost six years, I’d never been to an international music festival before. So when the opportunity came for me to fly north to check out POP Montréal, I jumped.
Perhaps a little too fast, actually. When it came time to book my ticket, about four months out from the actual fly date, I realized my passport had expired a year ago. Whoops. Thanks to a downloaded passport photo app and the expense of an expedited fee, this little oversight was handled. But what never really got done was the research.
You see, I had a real vacation scheduled for just a week prior to this trip. On top of that, there were weddings and my daily grind, and well, I never really found the time to do proper research. Oh sure, I had stuffed my Spotify with a whole bunch of albums from intriguing bands on the massive festival bill, but one thing happened after another, and I barely even scratched the surface of what to expect.
On top of that, I knew nothing about the city. I’m usually a madman when it comes to scouting information about a new place, especially one in a foreign country. This time, I didn’t even take the time to learn the basics of manners, communication, or transportation. Like a rookie chump, I was going in completely blind. I didn’t know what I was getting into with the city, let alone the festival.
So I did the only thing I could and tried to embrace it. What follows is a detailed account of my first-ever experience in Canada, in Montréal, at a city-wide music festival. I went in knowing no one and nothing. This is what I learned.
Wednesday, September 16th
11:30 a.m. — Before I even reach the airport, I’m wondering why I ever requested such an early flight. Landing at 11:30 sounded great when I considered getting a feel for Montréal before the festival really kicked into gear, but I can’t even check into my hotel until 3:00. Getting through the empty customs check is a breeze, though, and this is the unintentional genius of my timing. Turns out the folks coming into town later in the afternoon get logjammed for two hours just leaving the airport. Suckers.
I meet my driver, Sarah, outside the terminal. She tells me how she left a higher management position at MUTEK to become a lowly driver at POP, but says she enjoys having her feet on the ground, meeting people from all over, and experiencing things rather than running them. As we drive into downtown, she begins pointing out streets, directions, and points of interests. I’m told I’ll see plenty of construction-site orange, as summers always find Montréal in a state of repair. Sarah thinks it’s because Québécois aren’t the type of people who will fix something until it completely breaks down. I wonder in what state I’ll find POP Montréal.
12:52 p.m. — I’ve left my bags at the hotel and headed to lunch. By now, I’ve already “lost” my passport twice and made an ass of myself with this whole French thing at least a half dozen times. I’m sitting in a Frites Alors! restaurant on Boul St-Laurent. In front of me is my first-ever poutine and an iced coffee I thought was coming with cream but instead is mounded with whipped cream, chocolate sauce, and cherries. I’ll figure this French accent out yet.
Next up is check-in at POP HQ. The headquarters are housed in an old stone building that could either be a library made of tiny rooms or a boarding school with dark secrets. The setting only amplifies the uneasy thrill I’m experiencing. I feel like the new kid in town on the first day of classes — that exciting, nervous tension of being in a city, a country you’ve never been to before, alone, doing something you’ve never done before. Sure, I’ve attended city fests like this, but never in a city or a country where I’m such a stranger. I’m lost, but oddly content in the mystery of it all.
2:25 p.m. — On the way back to check into my hotel, I technically see my first band. There’s a welcome BBQ happening in the small grassy space outside HQ, and a strange beat is pulsing from within. I walk over to find Nick Persons hunched over a synth, dressed in a brightly colored Hawaiian shirt and yelling (as best I can tell) “I believe!” over and over into a microphone modulated to the point of sounding robotic. Off to the side, two girls in high-waist shorts and belly shirts dance (read: swing their arms wildly) to the drummer’s syncopated beats, clearly dying in the heat of the sun. The set ends before I can ready my camera. Canadians are weird.
I stick around for the first few songs from LOC-NAR, a slackercore outfit with stoned spasms of noise and nice, breezy grooves. A man with a bicycle pulls up directly in front of the keyboardist, soaking in the sounds from as close as possible until a guard asks him to move. He locks up his bike, pulls up a chair right back where he started, and lights a cigarette. Off to the side, a Mick Jagger-looking gentleman with a yarmulke is tweeking out before abruptly turning to leave mid-dance move. Canadians are weird.
6:20 p.m. — Once I’m settled at the hotel, I walk back to the POP BBQ to check out who the next surprise guest artist is. I’d heard Fanfaraï’s African jam jazz from my room’s balcony and am bummed that I arrive just as they are packing it in, but am pleased to see Ought start to set up. The local outfit has a British cadence to their sarcastic post-punk, a vibe that is engrossing on record but may miss the mark in an open show like this. “We’re not really an outside band,” frontman Tim Darcy admits. Though he runs and bops in place with the utmost energy, the crowd is all chatter and lounging, and the music sadly doesn’t get to shine. It couldn’t have been easy to follow Fanfarï’s vibe, either, but I may check Ought out again at their official show later in the week.
7:40 p.m. — After nearly walking nose-first into Win Butler’s shoulder inside POP HQ, I’m waiting in line for a bus to take me three kilometers northwest to my next venue. Yes, I said “in line”; people here actually form and respect a line for public transportation, and the bench at the stop counts. Compared to the hordes pushing through New York City transit, it’s one of the first signs of the relative pleasantness for which Canada’s famous.
I’ve messed up my understanding of time and arrived an hour before the set I want to catch at Théâtre Fairmount, so I stop by the Fédération Ukrainienne to see whoever’s playing. The venue is an old-style meeting hall, with ancient, wooden folding seats lining the floor and a large semi-circle balcony. Molly Sweeney is on stage delivering some sort of psych-blues-folk. “I used to be a folk singer,” she says, “but then I got a rock band.” It’s really still a folk band, though, and not a great one. Her voice is average, and frankly unpleasant on the screams. But she does show talent, switching between autoharp, tiple, and electric guitar on every song. The sound is interesting if nothing else, but I wonder how much of it gets chewed up in the venue. Ought is scheduled here for their next gig, and I’m a little less inclined to make it out again after hearing this.
9:00 p.m. — Your surf punk band wishes it was Les Breastfeeders. I’m at the newly, spectacularly renovated Fairmount checking out the ridiculously named opening act, and they are absolutely destroying. The entire crowd is shimmying hard to three guitarists, two excellent lead singers, and a poor man’s Alice Cooper smashing a tambourine, jumping between the stage extensions, spitting liquid into the air, and wearing a top hat. I don’t have the slightest idea what they’re singing as it’s entirely in French, but it sounds like “party” to me. The last time I had an awakening like this for a band I couldn’t understand was when I caught Stromae at SXSW. I now want more of Les Breastfeeders every day of my life.
10:15 p.m. — Your grandpa’s garage rock band wishes it was The Sonics. Even with Gerry Roslie’s hands shaking and his glasses strapped to his head, the guy still has the best “old guy” voice I’ve ever heard. Same goes for saxophonist Rob Lind, who rocks his grandpa gut harder than anyone. Bassist Freddie Dennis, while not an original member, brings a whole bunch of charm and an impeccable yowl to the group. Dusty Watson, known for bashing the drums on Lita Ford’s solo debut and as a member of The Queers, demolishes his kit, easily passing for a 30-year-old rock star. Together, these guys could shame half the garage rock acts on Hype Machine.
The crowd wholeheartedly loves every second of it. Everyone is singing along and dancing, hard — not thrashing about uncontrollably, but genuinely enjoying the music. The packed venue offers a glimpse at how different a Montréal crowd is from the Boston or NYC audiences in which I’ve historically found myself. As a whole, they’re not so cautious of showing their joy by moving their body, goofily or ecstatically, but at the same time are considerate of their fellow concertgoers. One guy gets kicked out around the fifth song, but for the most part there’s a respect shown here I sadly see far too infrequently in the States.
As packed as the place is, I’m easily allowed to move up front during the first three songs as I snap pictures and get thanked — sincerely, warmly thanked — when I move my six-foot-three frame back into the crowd. The last show I shot in NYC was Father John Misty at Central Park’s Summerstage, a venue with a huge photo pit I occupied with maybe seven other photographers. When we left after the first three songs, a girl in the front row sneered, “Good, leave. Get out of here,” as if we had ruined her whole night. These Montréalais don’t begrudge me my job, nor do they scoff at anyone trying to move through the crowd in any direction (and no one dares attempt the dickish push to the front we’ve all been guilty of). Even when I accidently bump a man in the shoulder as I try to take an overhead shot from the back of the room, he apologizes to me and offers to move out of the way. Dude, what?
The Sonics put on an A+ show, and the crowd is welcoming in a way that’s sadly rare in my experience. Even Win Butler is able to stand in the back, mostly by himself, unaccosted and enjoying the show. I may be by myself in this place, but suddenly I’m not feeling quite so alone.
Thursday, September 17th
5:30 p.m. — Day two starts like an average work day, except instead of a home office, I’m sitting in a café on Av du Parc. This is my first encounter with a famed Montréal bagel, a food I never knew was deserving of the adjective. It’s not the star of my breakfast sandwich, but it’s light in a way New York bagels never dream of and extremely tasty.
Later on, I head up north to check out the opening of Puces POP, which the festival markets as a “do-it-yourself festival,” an artists’ craft fair. I choose for the first time to take a public bike, a Bixi, and within 30 seconds I realize I’ve made a huge mistake. It’s been years since I’ve ridden one of the two-wheeled contraptions, and I’m wearing black jeans and a thick cotton shirt. It’s not long before I’m uncomfortable, sweating, and my legs are cursing at me.
But on the way to Puces, I take the chance to admire the city’s architecture: a gorgeous church set against the bright blue sky, brownstone buildings made lively with multi-story murals. Most apartments and homes feature outdoor stairwells leading to the second floor residences, meaning no matter which level you’re on, when you enter your building, you walk into your apartment and not a shared foyer. Balconies jut out from nearly every building at every possible height, and it seems that if you live in Montréal and don’t have some sort of outdoor space, you’ve failed at real estate. Taking in my surroundings helps distract me from the poor choice in transportation, and the final stretch being mostly downhill doesn’t hurt.
Puces is located on the second floor of a building above a mediterranean restaurant and a clothing retailer. While the tables of crafts, jewelry, and clothing certainly remind me of markets from home, they lack that weird pretension of Brooklyn fleas. You have your artisanal chutneys, cheeses, and the best damn hot sauce I can’t legally transport back into the States with me. There are T-shirts and scarves made from “pre-loved” jeans, vinyl displays carved out of rescued wood, pillows stitched from recycled T-shirts. I’d call it “subtle hipster” — a toned-down, carefully crafted hipster with a refined edge and no desire to be ironically droll. I purchase an avocado-cocoa-vanilla popsicle and wish I could justify spending $25 CAD on that pillow made from an old Ghostbusters tee.
7:30 p.m. — I devour the best falafel sandwich I’ve had in ages and decide to switch up my plans, figuring I can catch the hometown premiere of Arcade Fire’s Reflektor Tapes before the three acts I want to see tonight. Walking towards the Théâtre Rialto, I realize Mile End feels the most like the Brooklyn of Montréal thus far, not leastwise because of the restaurant I pass called Brooklyn, nor the sudden increase in Hasidic Jews and bagel stores. There’s an energy and a feel of constant activity in this part of town. The brownstone buildings with their big stoops, the shop-lined streets, and the endless bustle of people mesh into a vibe that’s comfortably familiar.
8:15 p.m. — I’m sitting with my legs uncomfortably scrunched against the seatback in front of me and wondering if Arcade Fire has screwed me. It’s 15 minutes after the film was meant to start, and I need about 25 to get to the next venue before Twin River goes on.
The Rialto is huge and gorgeous. Stained glass ceilings burn dimly in the warm light, ringed by frescoes of cherubs and gold accents. The ground floor is a large open square filled with removable chairs, nearly all of which are situated under the impressive balcony with its classic folding theater seats and considerably better vantage points of the massive stage. Bored and impatient, I start trying to take a long-exposure shot of the ceiling, limited by the location of my armrest tripod. The lonely photog waiting for a show to begin, unable to use his cellphone for fear of using up his travel data package — again.
Five minutes later, there’s a whole lot of French as Win Butler, Régine Chassagne, Tim Kingsbury, and Jeremy Gara are welcomed to the stage with fierce applause. Chassagne greets the crowd with more French, and then Butler presents his “commencement speech for the graduating class of POP Montréal 2015.” He shares George Orwell’s famous quote about writing being like a struggle with “some painful illness,” and offers advice to all writers and artists in the room to not be afraid of pretension and simply get their art into the world.
It’s funny that he mentions pretension, because I happen to find Reflektor the band’s most pretentious album. Unfortunately, Kahlil Joseph’s movie does little to dispel that feeling. It’s more of an arthouse film than any sort of documentary or concert movie, what with all the non-linear time jumps, the blending of different shows, the warping of audio, and the tracking shots of various pretty locations Arcade Fire found themselves in while forming the album. All the conversation is in voiceover, so unless you’re familiar with each band member’s voice, you’re never really sure who’s talking. Not that it matters, as every time it appears like an interesting insight is coming, Joseph backs away. He touches far too briefly and with little clarity on Chassagne’s Haitian heritage, randomly shifts focus to her relationship with Butler, and only offers the briefest tease of the band’s work with James Murphy. About the only thing you do learn is where the masks and costumes from the Reflektor tour originated, and that’s actually a tangential observation never explicitly discussed.
A film like this should make you want to go back and explore the album, especially if you weren’t too hot on it in the first place. I’m intrigued to listen to Reflektor again, but I’m certainly not rushing to grab my headphones. Despite the emphatic “wow” and applause from the woman behind me during the credits, I don’t think many in the theater were impressed with what they saw. There were more than a few snoozers. At brunch a few days later, I’ll meet a woman who has two films showing at POP and claims to know Joseph personally and calls Reflektor Tapes “an embarrassment.”
And I totally don’t have time to get to Twin River now.
10:30 p.m. — Instead, I stroll Av du Parc at an atypically leisurely pace. I grab a Taiwanese coffee drink at the supermarket that encircles the entrance to and sits beneath Théâtre Fairmount, where scheduling fate finds me once again. The venue is far emptier and smokier than it was last night. A friend I make tomorrow will suppose it’s because Calvin Love is from Canada, and the Canadians who make up most of POP’s attendance would rather catch non-local acts. As a US delegate, my priorities are the reverse.
Though he’s advertised as “a true rock star,” it takes a bit of imagination to picture Love owning the night in this situation — but only a bit. With the right crowd, his crooning, echoing pop rock could turn into a great show. He has charisma, a Wolfman-meets-Robert Pattinson look, and a loose guitar sound that’s bolstered by a killer drummer. Though there’s a spark missing due to the lack of kindling in the room, Love makes the most of it and keeps those in attendance more than warm. “Feel free to move forward, mill around,” he beckons before his opening number. “Let’s get intimate. This one’s about government conspiracies.”
11:50 p.m. — Before Mikal Cronin takes the stage, I’m recognized by a PR guy I’m 95% sure I’ve never actually met in person. Strange as his sudden appearance is, it’s nice to be noticed and have a real conversation with someone. He’s the third person to tell me about Montréal bagels, but the first to mention smoked meat sandwiches. I make a mental note for lunch tomorrow.
Having a friendly interaction has lifted my spirits, putting me in just the right headspace for a Cronin’s show. With a talent that could command a crowd half or twice this size with little change, he’s a true garage rock star maintaining a level of beauty you don’t find in many of his peers. It feels like he could be playing a friend’s basement show right now and his reserved pose and easy-going vibe would remain constant, the crowd’s reception just as welcoming. Listening to the vocals or guitars, watching his hands or his feet or the small smiles that shine onto his face, it’s all the same joyous feeling, and the crowd absorbs every drop. Even when I take a pee break, the guy at the urinal next to me and I can’t help bopping a bit to “Get Along”.
In the best spirits I’ve been in yet, I say goodbye to my PR friend and catch a cab back to the hotel.
Friday, September 18th
3:00 p.m. — After another working morning, I follow last night’s recommendation and grab a smoked meat sandwich for lunch. I choose Schwartz’s because why wouldn’t I choose an old Jewish deli for something like this? Apparently this shop is rather famous, even having a musical written about it a few years back. The sandwich is solid — layers of meat thicker and warmer than your typical pastrami sandwich loosely held between two tiny slices of bread and a just-thin-enough layer of mustard. The homemade fries are equally quality, and I sort of wish I could pig out enough to try the smoked meat poutine. But I have some weddings coming up and suit pants I need to fit into, so I head off to the CIMA (Canadian Independent Music Association) cocktail hour at POP HQ.
Standing in line for my first drink, I’m recognized by a guy I in turn recall from the Reflektor Tapes. I also remember him disappearing halfway through, and though he says he had a show to catch, he admits to feeling similarly to me about the film.
I’ll later learn that this particular photographer is decently known within the scene. Though he’s from Ottawa and plainly awkward, I will see him repeatedly throughout the remaining days talking up bands from all across Canada. It’s through him that I meet a local photographer who I end up feeling rather friendly towards, a writer from Clash, and a writer from Brooklyn Vegan. I start hearing the names of Canadian bands I don’t know, filling in the gaps in my lack of research, which ends up sending me towards the Rialto to catch She-Devils.
6:10 p.m. — Turns out this She-Devils set is actually a session recording at Espace POP, a second-floor, windowed storefront that hangs over the street. People are walking, biking, driving by, some stopping on the other side of the street to watch, one girl passing through with her cellphone recording the performance.
The band is a two-piece, described accurately on their Facebook page as “shy.” They’re playing one song over and over, her with her lipstick-stained microphone, him twiddling with his electronic gear in an opened suitcase. It’s some nice electro-ambi-jazz-pop hybrid, something to vibe to, but hearing the song over and over again doesn’t really sell me on them. My new photographer friend is here too, and she and I chat between takes.
I ask a guy who appears to be a fan next to me if he knows what the track is called (“How Do You Feel”), and he offers that they’re playing a full set at a non-official show tomorrow. He shows me the address and schedule, and I make an audible noise as I note that Majical Cloudz is opening. He simply says, “Yeah.” It takes me about another minute until I suddenly recognize him as Devon Welsh of Majical Cloudz. He was trying to hype up his friends in She-Devils instead of focusing on my acknowledgement of his band, and I’m impressed by his modesty. I hand him my card, and am more intrigued by this Arbutus Records day party knowing he’ll be there.
7:20 p.m. — I’m feeling run down, so my new friend and I go grab a cup of coffee at a nearby Greek café. Somehow we turn to politics, and I’m impressed by her knowledge of the US primary mess. She fills me in on the details of Canada’s current election cycle (an enviable three months that she calls “long”), and has informed insight about everyone from Bernie Sanders to Howard Dean. I can’t even remember Carly Fiorina’s name.
We part ways and I head to try a dinner prepared by Owen Pallett. There’s a clubhouse space between the three venues within the Rialto, where a different local celebrity chef or musician prepares a unique menu each night. As intriguing as the fried ball of breakfast called a Scotch egg looks, I go with Pallett’s onglet baguette, a French hanger steak sandwich classic. Pallett’s actually back there preparing the food, and I watch him deliver the final product to the order taker. Cooked beautifully but just slightly too rare and topped with a sweet, subtle red wine and shallot sauce, the sandwich is perfectly delicious, knocking that smoked meat sandwich from earlier out of the water.
I eat at a table with Pallett’s own publicist, two folks from Arbutus Records, and the PR gent who recognized me at Mikal Cronin, who introduces me to everyone here and lets me try a bite of his Scotch egg. We shoot industry shit and I learn just how difficult it is for Canadian artists to tour the US, including a tale about Grimes’ first stateside jaunt and the trick her dad pulled to help them transport equipment across the border.
9:00 p.m. — I hop my first Canadian Uber (or “You-bur,” as my driver calls it) to my first small bar venue, Petit Campus, for a change of pace. I’m warned by Pallett’s publicist that taxi drivers can get aggressive with Ubers here, so I sit in the front seat so to not draw suspicion.
At Campus, a spacious yet cramped room on the second floor of a building on the Prince Arthur promenade, I catch the first three or four songs of rockabilly family outfit Kitty, Daisy, and Lewis. Their swinging jump blues draws quite a crowd, and it’s enjoyable enough. With the girls dressed in spandex onesies and the gent dressed in a simple suit, it’s hard to figure out if they want to be a rock band or a country act, but it works for the audience either way. It’s not enough to keep me from leaving early to make sure I get into Giorgio Moroder, though, and I depart after their single “Baby Bye Bye”.
I walk through quiet residential streets until I come upon a huge old church — St. Jean Baptiste — with massive beats and flashing lights bursting forth through the stained glass windows. Organ Mood is finishing up their set, and though I’ve never said electronic music was my thing, I wish I’d come here first instead of Petit Campus. The visuals and beats the Québécois duo are putting out are captivating and invigorating. With projected images up on the chancel and even the giant chandeliers flashing with the rhythms, it seems like I missed one hell of a show.
Which is a shame, because it’s something the legendary Moroder fails to match. The 74-year-old isn’t known to be as adept at DJing as he is at producing, but shows like this do not do him any justice. Hits like “Love to Love You” and “Flashdance … What a Feeling” being squashed up against Kygo’s “Firestone” and Avicii’s “Levels” is awkward as heck, and feels like pandering from a man with so much status that such indulgences are completely unnecessary. Watching him try to clap with surprisingly “old man” rhythm only highlights how unsure of this style of performance he really is.
To be fair, the crowd loves it anyway. A giant dance party in this giant church painted with lasers and lights is hard to hate on. They sing along to “Hot Stuff” when he drops out the vocals, and cheer at the first recognizable notes of every classic hit. From my vantage up in the loft, it seems there’s rarely a still moment in the crowd — though, to be equally fair, some of that movement is reduced to fanning during the less beloved modern radio hits. It’s stifling hot in this place, so much so that the glue holding my earplugs together actually melts and the rubber gets stuck in my ear. Unable to fully enjoy this amateurish DJ mixing and at that point of hydration where I feel dehydrated even though my urine is crystal clear, I wander off into the night.
11:30 p.m. — I have a destination in mind for an hour from now, but in the meantime I just want a beer. I choose a random venue with an artist I barely recognize by name, Alex Calder. Club Lambi is filled with the youngest crowd I’ve seen yet, and Calder is appeasing them with his sloppy slacker lo-fi. There’s no grace in the tunes, doubly evident when the band drops out halfway through their closing number and lets their guitarist choose a random Foo Fighters song to cover. He plays the first few bars of “Rope”, which no one seems to recognize, and the rest of the band can only follow through the intro. They laugh at their own ineptitude and hop back to the final chorus of Calder’s own song. They sound like they’re rehearsing, and I can’t finish my beer fast enough.
12:30 a.m. — There’s still too much time between Calder and the final band I’m planning on seeing tonight. I notice an act called Country is scheduled nearby, and having heard the name multiple times from local media, I figure why not? Inside the basement bar L’Escogriffe, I find my photo phriend and some POP personnel. I’m offered a shot dubbed “the Pickle Vodka,” which is simply a shot of vodka with a pickle garnish/chaser. It’s fine, but nothing to compete with a good ol’ Pickle Back.
The venue is completely packed when Country comes on. The two-piece floats great ’80s guitar riffs over pre-programmed beats and synth beams, with frontman Beaver Sheppard’s vocals echoing off into infinity. It’s like new wave got drunk on drone music. Sheppard comes off as the goofy guy who fronted the band at your friend’s house party whose playful sincerity somehow garnered a following. Though Sheppard’s engaging, what David Whitten is doing on guitar and keys is more interesting. It’s a fun show, but the fact that a cramped space feels spacious after three songs either says something about their staying power or the venue.
01:30 a.m. — Country started late, which means I’m now catching only the tail end of the band for which I began my post-Moroder journey, Saxsyndrum. I find the electronic experimental jam duo accompanied by a vocalist and cellist rocking out in the large La Vitrola performance space in front of a completely joyous crowd. Though they’re not largely known outside their Montréal scene, what these guys do with their weird noise jazz is well worth the party. Their energy tonight is electric, maybe because of what’s brought by these added players, or perhaps it’s the POP excitement. Whatever it is, they’re absolutely owning their funk. As wiped out as I feel, I’m glad I stuck it out to catch these guys. Not only is it a highlight performance, but talking to the band afterwards will open up a door that gives me a personal peek into the Montréal music scene.
Saturday, September 19th
1:45 p.m. — I join my fellow delegates for brunch at Café Parvis, where we’re served an egg and sausage breakfast pizza, poached eggs over a hashbrown patty, and some absolutely killer banana nut cake. Next to me is a guy from a Canadian electronic music PR firm who reaffirms my feelings about Moroder. He tells me that the Arbutus show is way up north, and that the POP HQ shows I’d planned on attending have been switched to Divan Orange due to an old woman’s noise complaint. I’m considering sucking it up and heading on the bike tour I’ve signed up for, but when he and a Norwegian woman from Øya Festival invite me to share their Uber up to Arbutus, I tag along.
3:00 p.m. — Though he’s from Toronto, the PR guy makes for a suitable replacement tour guide as we drive up to the warehouse space where the Arbutus show is being held. The DIY venue is a sparse garage, but it’s been dressed up in spectacular fashion. There are tables with books on display and floor-to-ceiling floating vinyl displays made from industrial parts. Little rectangular ponds have been cut into the floors, filled with green plants and a few actual fish. There’s even a little waterfall coming out the DJ stand, behind which is a black Ford Explorer covered in a clear plastic tarp.
“All right, we’re gonna start the show now,” an unassuming Devon Welsh says, drawing the small crowd around him. Wearing the same shirt I saw him in yesterday, Welsh is clearly nervous. His hands shake visibly, and he more than once inhales deeply or twitches uncomfortably. He’s always seemed a shy performer, but the added pressure here is largely because he’s unveiling non-Majical Cloudz songs that he says he hasn’t “really practiced before.”
Practiced or not, the tracks he performs are beautiful. The first one in particular is vulnerable and candid, Welsh pushing through his nerves to sing clearly, “I hope/ I am scared/ I feel faint/ But you are someone I won’t turn away.” Though the lyrics are simple, they’re touching, and Welsh’s delivery is just incredibly sincere. “I know you’re far away,” he sings on the second song’s hook. “Just help me come home/ Starlight,” and it’s dazzling. I don’t know where these tracks may show up in the future, but they’re stunningly powerful and deserve to be heard outside of this concrete garage.
4:10 p.m. — I drink a free Kronenbourg 1664 and grab some spicy chicken satay barbecue before She-Devils. Maybe I’m just not in the mood right now or maybe it’s just headphone music, but their sound doesn’t have the pull to keep me in place. (Most of those who seem to enjoy the show are doing so with eyes closed, rocking slightly.) Learning that the BBQ shows have indeed moved back to POP HQ, I catch the bus back down to see Nick Diamonds of Islands.
It’s just Nick and his electric guitar, his setlist written out on his phone, which he keeps checking and joking that his mom won’t stop texting. He runs through only a few new City of Quartz tracks, sprinkling his set with classic Islands songs and a few covers (Jonathan Richmond’s “That Summer Feeling” and Arthur Russell’s “Nobody Wants a Lonely Heart”). He even debuts some fresh Islands material, which draws plentiful applause from the small crowd. As the first few drops of rain fall, crew members start bustling around covering equipment and the crowd slowly shuffles under a few small tents and umbrellas. “Why’s everyone acting strange?” Nick jokes. “It’s fine where I am.” He then delivers The Unicorns’ “Ready to Die” as a final number, and caps off a mellow set perfectly situated on a lazy, overcast day that slowly gives way to drizzle.
5:00 p.m. — It turns out The Muscadettes’ set has been called off not because of rain, but because their sound would’ve violated noise complaints. I’m bummed I skipped them yesterday, but there’s nothing I can do but hide from the weather inside HQ and drink some free beers. I chat with my photog friend and the Øya staffer about music festivals and cats.
9:10 p.m. — Following a work respite at the hotel, I pick up my first 24-hour metro pass. I probably could’ve used a three-day pass over the course of this trip, but it slipped my mind until my new Toronto PR friend mentioned it. Either way, I figure I’ll be using it a bit over the final day of the fest, beginning with a trip back to the Fairmount to catch Arts & Crafts’ showcase. I’m handed a mixtape cassette upon checking in, and am told that all the T-shirts, sweaters, and vinyl records along the railing are up for grabs. None of the clothing would fit me, but I snag Calvin Love’s LP and a 4-LP A&C compilation. Hopefully I can find space in my bags to get these home.
Charlotte Day Wilson is opening the show, filling in for a canceled Farao, and the solo singer may be the best female vocalist I’ve heard at POP. Alone with her guitar and loop pedals, she has a voice that reminds me of a sturdier Lady Lamb. The Toronto songwriter also keeps her folk tunes from exploding in the way the Brunswick/Boston/New York songwriters do, instead relying on those loops to create self-reflected harmonies that swell and break in gentle relief.
At my impromptu tour guide’s suggestion, I’ve come early to check out River Tiber. He’s up next, and I discover another Toronto artist who puts on a winning performance. Performing solo instead of with his usual backing band, Tommy Paxton-Beesley does a fine job holding things down by himself. His electro-R&B eschews the razzle-dazzle that others in the genre play with, opting instead for unhostile beats and reverberating guitar strums. Even his vocals stay cool, lacking the big breaks and bombast that can sometimes overwhelm similar artists. I know I’m in Montréal, but Toronto’s doing just fine.
10:07 p.m. — While I’m excited to be witnessing more Canadian acts, I walk over to Rialto Hall to catch a Swedish one. Small Feet have come to Montréal down one member, so the trio is performing as a two-piece. I’m more into frontman Simon Stålhamre’s vocals, anyway, so being a man short doesn’t bug me too much. On the slower numbers, his voice takes on a medieval quality, like a bow pulling across violin strings. The band has a good range of melancholic smoldering numbers and sturdy, dusty drivers, and even with just guitar, drums, and keyboards, they put on a fine display of Nordic folk. With some of the simplest, most affecting indie folk coming from that part of the world, fingers crossed Stålhamre grows his band enough that they can come back in full force sometime soon.
11:10 p.m. — On my way back to Fairmount, I scarf down some pad thai and free spicy pakoras from Nantha Kumar’s POP-up restaurant at Clubhouse POP. When I re-enter the venue, I’m greeted by a wall of drone provided by Absolutely Free. At first I’m sure I’ve finally met a Toronto act I can’t stand, but then the sound breaks into a movable groove and suddenly my head’s bobbing along. The beats are hypnotic, a little like Animal Collective. At times feeling like a swarm of noise, the subtle tempo shifts and inescapable rhythms make it easy to see why they’ve drawn such a crowd. Win Butler is here yet again, as are Nick Schofield and David Switchenko of Saxsyndrum, who sit right in front of me and block my view.
I’m far from annoyed at the guys, though, and as soon as Absolutely Free shuts down I butt into their conversation. It’s at this point that I unsuspectingly tap directly into the Montréal scene. They explain that they’re part of a loose collective in town called Oh Hi that includes Sea Oleena, Holobody, themselves, Year of Glad (Saxsyndrum’s sister project led by the vocalist and cellist who joined them the night prior), Smokes, and this guy called Commander Clark.
Clark is a relative newbie in town, but after only a year, he’s gained quite a reputation. Working mainly as a flyer designer and poster, he literally burst onto the scene by nearly getting into a fight with someone at a DIY show. He wasn’t looking for trouble, as it turns out, just so completely loving the music that he had to thrash out. I’d witnessed some of this while taking pictures of Absolutely Free, and I get a full face of his unstoppable energy when he comes over to talk with Saxsyndrum. He’s like a side character from an old Cameron Crowe film, lovable but ridiculous, captivating yet sort of terrifying in his all-out attitude. Whatever he is, he’s a candle burning bright in Montréal. I just hope it’s not from both ends.
I tell Saxsyndrum I’m afraid I haven’t caught enough Montréal acts, and they instantly recommend Nancy Pants, another Oh Hi member. The trio happens to be playing in just a few minutes at Divan Orange, a local favorite spot I’ve been meaning to check out. Dave’s heading that direction for a different show and offers to guide me, so off I go to check out a real Montréal band at a real Montréal venue.
12:00 a.m. — Dave and I chat about the scene, Montréal fests, and POP in general on our way down to our shows. He’s incredibly friendly, and tapped deeply into the scene and the city; we can’t even walk five blocks without him bumping into someone he knows.
We part ways on the next corner and I head down to Divan Orange, a dark, packed little club with friendly staff and a happy crowd. Nancy Pants take the stage, and I’m instantly captivated by frontwoman Ohara Hale. Her smile is as infectious as the band’s pleasant pop rock. They carry a doo-woppy flow that keeps things playful, and their stage presence takes it all to the next level. At different points, Hale breaks a guitar string and borrows another band’s instrument, jokes about how fast one of the songs is, and practically giggles after finishing a number she says is “so fun to play;” whatever it is, she’s smiling and bouncing and loving it. The crowd is, too, as I witness my first balloon bounce and crowd surfer of the whole fest. And there’s Commander Clark up front, rocking out and getting a shout out from Hale.
While Hale is the clear star here, the band’s chemistry is equally impressive. Bassist Adam Waito carries a few tunes himself, though it’s hard to match Hale’s pop, and drummer Jeremy MacCuish is pretty spectacular. I’m thinking these guys are the first small Canadian outfit I’ve seen that I can imagine really breaking out when I find Saxsyndrum’s Nick at the bar. He tells me MacCuish is actually Smokes’ drummer too, and is in fact a stalwart of the Montréal scene. Hale came up as an graphic designer and poster artist, while Waito works for a music publisher. These three are vital to Montréal music as individuals, and an altogether force as a band.
It’s fascinating being suddenly so “in touch” with the local scene, and through Saxsyndrum, I feel like I’m being welcomed inside to learn more. It’s a testament to both the city’s talent and warmth. Speaking of warmth, the bar is hot as demon breath. According to Nick, there’s rarely AC at this time of year, but it’s also never this warm. Good weather has its downsides.
Sunday, September 20th
3:15 p.m. — Not that I have the space to pack anything more, but I go to check out the record fair being held in St. Michel Church. The smell of old vinyl sleeves wafts up from the basement as I enter, and I wish I had the funds, time, or space to really shop. Right away, I notice Nick at the entrance, and within seconds find Dave flipping through dollar 7-inches. Wouldn’t you know it, Nick runs this event every year, too, gathering record slingers from across the city and bringing them together under one roof. These Saxsyndrum guys are everywhere.
6:45 p.m. — After making sure I have real poutine one last time, I also make sure to take a walk up Mount Royal. In the park around Monument à Sir George-Étienne Cartier, I discover that the hippie is alive and well, and it lives in Montréal. There’s a percussion fest going on, with multiple drum circles in all different corners of the space, blending African rhythms with psyched-out dancing. There’s the clear smell of marijuana, with the distributors easily spotted on the fringe of the crowds. Hacky sack games are going on in various courts, and vendors are selling different versions of the same baggy harem pants and cotton sling bags. As I make my way up the hill, I pass rock climbers, tents smelling of weed, and people prepping campfires. I walk along the gravel path while runners pass by and find my way towards the stairs leading to the Chalet du Mont-Royal.
The wooden steps are numerous and winding, but I make it panting to the top just as the colors of sunset begin to spread across the sky. Layers of dying light blossom clear and even over the city, the trees, the distant mountains before me. I’ve been relegated to essentially one strip of road from downtown up to Mile End, and this view is quite literally the most of the city I’ve seen the entire time. I haven’t explored every nook of the place, though what I’ve experienced has given me nothing but positive notions about the town and — as far as one can reasonably extend it — Canada in general. The people have been warmhearted and well-disposed, and the music so clearly filled with love and positivity. One day I’ll have to return to really dig in without a festival schedule dictating my whereabouts.
For the first time all trip, I’m chilly — nose-runningly chilly. I can see my hotel from here.
9:00 p.m. — I’m back at Divan Orange for my final show of the week. Sure, it’s an international touring bill, but options are thin on Sunday here and the headliner is one of my must-sees. Fake Limbs open, and it’s not the type of show at which I’d typically find myself. Noise/hardcore isn’t my bag, but dammit if Stephen Sowley doesn’t make you just love this band. I walk in to find him stalking up and down the center of the club, screaming with his mic in the face of a crowd member who can only stand there and smile sheepishly. A few seconds later he’s up on a table in the back of the club, yelling at nobody and leaning his head against a pipe on the ceiling. “Yeah, and that’s just the second song,” he quips with a smile. Personable, funny, and impish despite his giant size, you have to love him even if you can’t make out a word he’s yelling through the shitty sound system.
9:50 p.m. — Which makes follow-up act Heat kind of hard to swallow. A local band gaining international favor by hooking up with this tour, their largely serviceable rock songs lack the energy to be comfortably sandwiched between Fake Limbs and the headliner. The crowd has gone from sparse to almost full, though, so it seems to work fine for some folks. Or at the least they’re getting support as hometown heroes. Even the singer’s banter is low on enthusiasm though, and it largely fails to keep my interest.
10:40 p.m. — But then there’s Bully to the rescue. Even with her hair draped over her face, Alicia Bognanno has more personality than all four members of Heat combined. Her lyrics pack such a clean punch through her yelps and crackles on record, and I’m thrilled to see that emotion so precisely recreated on stage. Bass lines remain bouncy even as the dual guitars shred and the drumming thwaps like leather on skin, combining for a furious sound that remains playful and easily maintains a high vitality. The band is fresh out on this tour, their first as major headliners, and you can tell they’re still enjoying the heck out of it. Hopefully they can keep these spirits up, because this has easily been one of the best shows of the fest.
12:00 a.m. — The night is over. I intend to head back to pack and sleep, but a POP staffer and my favorite photog pal convince me to come out for just one drink at the closing party. It’s back up at the Clubhouse, and I split a cab with another POP member, a DJ who used to book hip-hop acts for SXSW, and a friend of a friend. Everyone’s here tonight: Beaver Sheppard is running the POP-up restaurant, every friendly media face I’d seen all week is milling around, and musicians I’d watched on stage the night before are hugging those I’d seen three days ago.
Downstairs, a supergroup of local talent is kicking off a Talking Heads cover set. With a car coming for me at seven in the morning, there’s no way I can stay for The Smiffs, another supergroup doing all Smiths numbers. But I’m glad I came to take the opportunity to say goodbye to the media I’d bonded with, the POP staffers who did a fantastic job of organizing such a massive event, and the musicians that welcomed this outsider into their local family with open arms.
From the outside, Montréal isn’t really that different from many other big cities. What makes it stand out, however, is the ties between the people. There’s a mutual respect, regardless of personal feelings, that makes navigating these streets not only easy, but pleasant. You can see it in those public transit lines, in the conversations with the Uber drivers, in everything Saxsyndrum does. So many cities have little communities sustaining themselves against others. Here, it seems like there’s just the Montréalais, all in it together, all speaking French, and all with such high spirits. Anywhere else in the world, my initial loneliness might have gotten the better of me. Here, it waned more and more each day, and I leave hoping it’s not the last time I see some of these people, and certainly some of these bands.