Top Episodes is a feature in which we handpick the definitive best episodes of a groundbreaking, beloved, or otherwise awesome television series. This article originally ran in 2017 and has been updated.
In December 1997, I threw up on Jason Alexander.
Well, maybe it was at his feet — the jury’s still out.
Alexander, then about to enter his final season portraying the neurotic and quick-tempered George Costanza, was enjoying a pleasant breakfast buffet in Maui. Almost seven years old and raised in a household where Seinfeld was routinely on TV, I had seen him around the resort for a few days, always too nervous to say anything. On my last morning before flying back home, my parents pushed me to approach his table; who could say no to an (allegedly) cute first grader?
But something happened on the short walk across the restaurant — my stomach started to churn, later giving way to the flu. When I opened my mouth to speak, only vomit came out.
“It was horrifying,” my dad says. “We didn’t know what to do!”
Since the last season of Seinfeld had likely been written at this point, I’ve long been curious why this incident never made it into Curb Your Enthusiasm, Larry David’s LA-based comedic tour de force, assuming Alexander told his producer and co-stars about the episode. But on second thought, it makes sense my story was never a random side plot — it wasn’t petty enough.
David, the real life version of George Costanza, complains and argues his way through dinner parties, frozen yogurt lines, celebrity birthday parties, memorial services, and virtually everywhere in Los Angeles, Manhattan, and at one point, a Parisian parking lot. Over the course of eight seasons, David and his friends with extremely high tolerances for bullshit float in and out of some of the most awkward and cringeworthy situations ever put on the small screen.
Of course David couldn’t have included a story about a kid puking up breakfast at his feet, because he first had to fight back against stop and chatters, teach a girl scout how to use a tampon, fire a chef for wearing a toupee, and argue with David Schwimmer’s father about the ratio of cashews to raisins in a trail mix package.
As our favorite bald respecter of wood returns this week, we decided to revisit our favorite Curb episodes, chock full of hair-raising awkwardness and some of the funniest one-liners in TV history.
And almost 20 years later, if by any chance you’re reading this Jason, I’m sorry.
— Steven Edelstone
20. “Shaq” from Season 2, Episode 8
Premiere Date: November 11, 2001
Are You Crazy? (Larry’s Big Issue) “Breaking news: death’s less important when the Lakers lose,” Earl Sweatshirt raps on Doris single “Hive,” a play on how important the Lakers are to the city of Los Angeles (at least when they’re good). Larry and Richard Lewis get Jeff’s courtside seats for the opening game of the season, right next to the Lakers bench. When Shaq runs to the scorers table to get subbed back in, Larry stretches out his legs, tripping the Lakers’ star player, knocking him out of the game. Everyone in Los Angeles hates Larry, even yelling at him on the street, but unexpectedly, everything starts going his way.
“Get the Fuck Outta My House, Larry!” (Susie Quote) One of the few episodes where Susie doesn’t appear, the best insult comes from Jeff, obviously furious after he loses his hard-won Lakers season tickets. “What the fuck, what the fuck?” he screams at Larry as he runs into him across the street. “What can I do? Can I do anything?” a defeated Larry asks. “Buy the team!” Jeff responds.
Vanilla Bullshit Things (The Best LD Observation): “Can someone tell me what they did to the bottom of the broccoli?” Larry complains to deaf ears at dinner in the episode’s opening scene. “Is there one person at this table that can eat cauliflower?” he continues, though the other five people at dinner, Cheryl included, completely ignore his whining.
He’s Not My Best Friend! (Hilarious Moment Involving Someone in Larry’s Circle) Surprisingly, most of Larry’s inner circle is absent for this episode, with Jeff only appearing in a couple scenes and Cheryl and Richard taking a sort of backseat to the general plot. The best moment involving any of the major characters comes in the form of Cheryl’s disapproving looks when Larry decides to buy the entire coffee shop whatever they wanted. “This new Larry is too enthusiastic. I miss the old Larry!” she complains.
Stop and Chat (This Episode’s Guest Star): By 2001, Shaquille O’Neal was coming off of a championship season and was the biggest star in his sport, so this was a huge get for the show. But as we all know now, Shaq is a hilarious personality, which showed throughout this episode. “The whole world knows that peanut butter is a dairy product,” he proclaims while playing Scattergories with perfect deadpan. Though he’s only on screen for maybe 25% of the episode, Shaq steals the show, as he nearly always does.
Socially Assassinated (Who Gets Fucked Over): The Lakers team doctor, Craig Wiggins (Joel McKinnon Miller), at Shaq’s hospital bedside following the injury, cheated at Scattergories, adding a couple extra words to his list after the timer ran out. Larry caught the doctor fudging the score and when Wiggins went to the bathroom, he told the star player about it, resulting in Shaq firing his doctor.
Episode as a GIF:
Get In That Ass (Best Advice Given): “Aren’t you going to say goodbye?” is the episode’s mantra, repeated multiple times as Larry fails to say goodbye or good night when he leaves social situations. It’s not the best or most pointed advice out of the show’s history, but it hilariously gets recalled towards the end when Cheryl’s parents decide to fly home early so they could “leave you with your chaos.”
Pretty, Pretty, Pretty Good (Analysis): “I get so much satisfaction out of seeing 19,000 people disappointed when they lose,” Larry says at the beginning of the episode (though he may not enjoy it when his team wins either). But his pleasure at seeing disappointment works out much better than he could have imagined — he gets out of having to write a letter of recommendation for an acquaintance and doesn’t have to make a page in a birthday book. For once, his being hated by everyone actually benefits him, flipping the script of how Larry’s usual interactions generally go.
— Steven Edelstone
19. “The Ski Lift” from Season 5, Episode 8
Premiere Date: November 20, 2005
Are You Crazy? While the preceding episodes don’t conceal it, “The Ski Lift” confirms one thing: there are no depths that Larry won’t sink to in order to avoid taking the kidney test to see if he’s a match for his bedridden friend, Richard Lewis. When he and Jeff are exposed for hoping Lewis’ comatose cousin Louis Lewis quietly passes on — thereby possibly giving Richard one of his kidneys — plan B is characteristically ambitious.
After discovering the head of the kidney consortium, Ben Heineman, is prone to helping out “friends,” Larry invites him and his daughter on a ski trip in the hopes of bumping Lewis up. How Larry gets to that point (and the way he conspires to convince the Orthodox Heineman father and daughter that he also practices) makes for a brilliantly mortifying 30 minutes.
“Get The Fuck Outta My House, Larry!” Consigned to the floor of the ski lodge during their stay, Larry tries to quietly climb in beside his fake Orthodox wife Susie in the middle of the night. With Jeff quietly accepting his lot on the floor in the next room, Larry screws up and Susie’s reaction is perfectly heartless. “You think I care about your back? Do you know how much I’ve done for you already this weekend? Get the fuck out of the bed!” Whimpering and shivering, Larry tries to explain that he’s cold. “GET THE FUCK OUT OF BED!” Susie makes her point loud and clear.
Vanilla Bullshit Things: Nearing the end of his tether, Lewis straight up tells Larry that he’s counting on him “stepping up” and taking the kidney test at the start of “The Ski Lift.” Before plucking up the courage for that, however, he absently whines to his old friend that his baseball hero Mickey Mantle, whose 500th home-run ball he owns, once got bumped up the list. Without missing a beat, Larry says, “Yeah, well, maybe if you were a bigger celebrity you’d be on the top of the list!” Sometimes the truth hurts but, seeing as Larry and Lewis’ friendship is largely based on being frank with each other, Larry’s scathing observation manages to transcend offense.
He’s Not My Best Friend! Larry rarely holds back when it comes to giving his small yet close circle of friends a piece of his mind. Every time he hangs Jeff out to dry with a cutting putdown or caustic observation? Chances are he’s coming from a good place. When he refuses to change how he acts around Lewis when he’s knocking on death’s door? That’s true friendship. Early on in “The “Ski Lift,” Larry refuses to budge on taking the kidney test for his old friend. After serving him with a putdown of his own, Lewis turns to Larry and says Larry’s sweater is appropriate for an Andy Williams Summer Show. Subtle enough, but also quite scathing.
Stop and Chat: From Hugh Hefner and Gary Player in “The Smoking Jacket” to Rosie O’Donnell in “The Bowtie,” Season Five of Curb You Enthusiasm has its fair share of guest stars cropping up here and there. Though it’s short-lived, comedian George Lopez advises Larry to befriend Ben Heineman, making him quite instrumental in how “The Ski Lift” plays out. “Buddy up to him, kiss his ass. Who knows? He’ll probably bump Richard up the list.” Were it not for, you know, Larry being Larry, he might well have.
Socially Assassinated: When Larry removes his glasses and tells Lewis’ nurse Lisa Thompson, “I think you took the ball, stashed it in your unusually large vagina, and marched right out of here,” the expression on Lewis’ face is an absolute joy to behold. Yes, Larry goes there. In another instance, his accusation would be pretty indefensible. But, seeing how Lisa a.) needlessly tries to convince Larry that her old flame, Jeff “These Big Vagina Ladies Are Getting Away with Murder” Greene is severely under-endowed and b.) did, in fact, steal Lewis’s baseball, Larry’s cell phone and god knows what else, Larry’s audacious claim actually winds up proving to be riotous. Still, if you can manage to watch this scene without your jaw hitting the floor, you’re probably not doing it right.
Episode as a GIF:
Get In That Ass: You know you’re really breaking down the walls of social taboo when Larry David — LARRY DAVID — turns to you, with an expression of mild disgust, and utters the words, “Way too much information, ok?” Although he isn’t wrong, when he offers up this counsel to Lisa early on in “The Ski Lift,” one can’t help but think he should consider heeding his own advice now and again.
Pretty, Pretty, Pretty Good: Although Season Five is arguably the weakest of the show’s eight seasons to date, “The Ski Lift” is a masterclass of highlights. Speckled with some exceptional one-liners from Larry, Lewis, Jeff, and others, it’s a by-the-book blueprint of how keeping it fairly streamlined and focusing on two or three narrative arcs is often key to making the finesse of Larry’s writing shine through. Finding LD to be someone who is prepared to adapt a totally new persona in order to shirk responsibility — as a man who offers a starving Orthodox woman edible panties as a snack — this is the definition of a watching-through-one’s-fingers episode.
— Brian Coney
18. “Chet’s Shirt” from Season 3, Episode 1
Premiere Date: September 15, 2002
Are You Crazy? Everything revolves around the episode’s namesake, which Larry first sees in a photo of Cheryl’s friend Barbara’s dead husband (that photo, by the way, is so hilariously humdrum). So taken by this two-toned black and white shirt, Larry ignores Barbara’s tears — hey, it’s been four months — and needles her about where her dead spouse got it. Eventually, he finds himself in ownership of three of them, one of which he gives to Ted Danson, who is irked when he realizes it has a tear in it — “You didn’t get me a gift,” he tells Larry, “you got me a defective shirt.” Things pretty much go downhill from there, despite Larry’s excitement about investing in a new high-end restaurant.
“Get the Fuck Outta My House, Larry!” No Susie this episode, but Larry is hilariously dressed down by a dude who’s apoplectic after seeing Larry throw an apple in his curbside trash can. “Next guy I see throwing garbage in there, I’m gonna kick his ass,” he warns. “I’ll give that message to the next guy,” Larry dryly responds.
Vanilla Bullshit Things: Larry’s potential investment in Bobo’s prompts plenty of restaurant industry observations. What’s with the lack of sweet potatoes in California dining, Larry asks, and why is it so hard to get a waiter’s attention. His solution to that latter issue? Bells at every table, each at a different tone so the waiters don’t get confused. “I’m so appalled by the idea that I’m struck dumb,” says fellow investor Michael York. Larry’s also very anti-kabob (a “kabobaphobe,” York quips): “I’m a little afraid of the stick, frankly.”
He’s Not My Best Friend! Ted wants Larry and Jeff to play Wizard of Oz characters at his daughter’s birthday party, and Jeff’s robust frame makes him a shoe-in for the Cowardly Lion. Unfortunately, Larry refuses to play the Tin Man — “I have no connection to the Tin Man” — and demands to play the Lion, resulting in Jeff relenting. “You do the lion,” he says. “I’ll be the fat Tin Man that’ll disappoint children.”
Stop and Chat: Ted’s a welcome presence any time he pops up, and “Chet’s Shirt” offers him an opportunity to show how he can be just as petty and obnoxious as Larry when it comes to the dumbest bullshit. Just look at them tugging the thing in the final moments — these are two children.
Socially Assassinated: Despite his good intentions, Ted ends up without a shirt and on the verge of an ass-kicking in the episode’s final moments. What he doesn’t realize is the dude who’s mad about Ted using his garbage can wouldn’t be nearly as pissed if it weren’t for his previous encounter with Larry. If Curb has one undeniable truth, it’s that Larry’s bad influence is ever rippling outward, ruining everyone who enters its orbit.
Episode as a GIF:
Get In That Ass: “If you give somebody a gift it’s supposed to be a gift, not a problem,” Ted says after Larry gives him a shirt with a hole in it and expects Ted to go get it fixed. Ted’s being kind of an asshole, but he’s not wrong.
Pretty, Pretty, Pretty Good: ”Chet’s Shirt” was the third season’s first episode, and here we see the show actively working to broaden its world. If the first two seasons felt relatively contained to Larry’s entertainment circles and comedy pursuits, the third season adds an extra layer with the restaurant storyline, which allows us to see our hero flailing around and annoying people in a world he doesn’t understand.
This episode also gives us one of Ted’s best performances, where he struggles not just with Larry’s behavior but with the general sense that their friendship is doomed. “Why are you doing this?!” Ted cries at one point. “Every time we get together we push and pull like this!” It’s such a genuine expression of frustration in a show that’s built on so many exaggerated behaviors, which of course only makes it funnier. On Curb, the realer the anger, the more hilarious it is.
— Randall Colburn
17. “The Seder” from Season 5, Episode 7
Premiere Date: November 13, 2005
Are You Crazy? Someone’s been taking Larry’s newspapers, and LD wants to get right down to the bottom of it. The good news is that he has two possible witnesses in “cranky neighbors” Mac and Ethyl, who claim they’ve seen a man in a suit roaming around his property. That juicy bit of information is enough for Larry to whittle down the suspect list to his other neighbor Dr. Mark (Rob Huebel), who has recently reunited with his estranged wife.
His return is one big exclamation mark for Larry, who theorizes that Mark may be snagging the papers out of spite, seeing how LD forgot to get him and his wife a Christmas gift earlier. Naturally, he uses his Seder dinner as a way to bring them all together… like a scheming count.
“Get the Fuck Outta My House, Larry!” Nobody’s psyched that Larry invited (friendly) sex offender Rick (Rob Corddry) to Seder, especially Cheryl who nearly has a panic attack on their stairwell earlier in the episode, but leave it to Susie to keep things real. “What the hell are you trying to pull, Larry?” she lights up with that Susie rage. “He should not be in our presence on a holy day. Any day. What the hell are you doing?”
Vanilla Bullshit Things: When Larry helps Mac and Ethyl with their groceries, he sees they bought some grape juice and beams with joy. “What is this? Grape juice? You guys drink grape juice? You never see people drinking grape juice. I think it’s a very underrated juice.” Of course, that camaraderie doesn’t extend to Mac’s own observation that everyone’s parked in front of his house for the Seder, to which Larry humorously protests: “Are you going out tonight? I think you’re here, aren’t you? So what’s the problem?”
When Mac continues to complain, stressing how this happens “every time [Larry] has a party,” Larry offers a BS apology and adds: “I’ll inform them next time.” Classic LD shrug-off.
He’s Not My Best Friend! Save for Jeff, who attends the Seder with Susie and Sammi, Larry’s Jewish rat pack sits this one out, leaving him all the time in the world to work on his golf swing and pal about with Rick the Sex Offender. Still, Jeff brings plenty to the table in this episode, pun intended, namely his conservative brother-in-law, Len Dunkel (Stephen Tobolowsky), who believes in all sorts of a wackadoo bullshit. “Have you heard of the theory, the 77?” he asks a befuddled Larry. “Okay, every 77 years there’s a great president. Washington, Lincoln, F.D.R., and… George W. Bush. We’re turning the whole damn world around.” Larry’s little grin says it all: You’re a fucking idiot.
Stop and Chat: Who would have thought that the one stop-and-chat to truly win over Larry would be from a sex offender? That’s kind of the joke, because really, out of all the run-ins from Curb history, few have warranted an unlikely friendship like that of Larry and Rick’s. On the surface, the guy’s a total ace in the hole: he’s got “the touch” for rickety newspaper boxes, he plays golf (and eats and breathes, in that order), he knows how to help others with their golf swing, he can make a whole batch of latkes, and he’s incredibly honest. But, he’s also a sex offender, and that’s just not good for anyone. Kudos to Corddry, though, for bringing charm to the character, and making us kind of see why LD would invite him over for dinner.
Socially Assassinated: Although he acts like Don Corleone all throughout the Seder — shaking down Dr. Mark the second he arrives with threats both passive (“Something wrong, doctor?”) and aggressive (“You took that paper. I know you did.”) — Larry’s hit list really only comes down to Len, who’s later outed by Larry for pointing his son toward the hidden matzoh/afikoman. But even that’s debatable given that the source of Larry’s information comes from Rick, who, in the “throes of a moral quandary,” confesses that he saw Len whisper the location to his son. Maybe it’s just Tobolowsky’s delivery, but the way Len spits back to Larry, “Oh, your friend the convicted sex offender!”, leads this writer to believe that nobody at the table really looks down upon Len. Then again, there’s very little time to process the information since Sammi starts choking soon after. Thank god for Rick!
Episode as a GIF:
Get In That Ass: It’s not the most orthodox of friendships, but Larry’s bond with Rick warrants a revelatory golf lesson for LD. After the two meet cute, they head back to Rick’s, where he helps Larry with his swing, all by using his state-of-the-art camera equipment to map out what he’s doing right and wrong. “Watch it in slow motion, okay,” he tells Larry, who he affectionally dubs his “best student of the day.” “Look at that. See, you’re bringing your hips through.” In any other situation, it might be a pleasant afternoon between two grown men, but then you remember Rick’s sordid past, and you immediately start questioning why he has this equipment, and the whole scene turns icky pretty, pretty… pretty fast.
Pretty, Pretty, Pretty Good: From strictly a narrative standpoint, “The Seder” works exactly like an old Seinfeld episode, specifically in the way that David weaves in an unlikable character into an unlikely situation, and wraps everything up with a baker’s bow. But, there’s something here that goes thematically deeper than your traditional episode, as if David’s actually trying to say something with the premise itself. By pairing Rick’s story with the traditional Passover Seder dinner, it’s almost like he’s commenting on the hypocrisy of our own social values, namely how we’re so easily wont to cast aside people as we try to preach about unity.
Sure, Rick fuels Larry’s ego, praising “The Puffy Shirt” episode and regaling him with all sorts of flattery, and that’s easily why he wins over LD, but there’s something to be said about Larry’s invitation. He didn’t have to invite him, but he felt guilty about not doing it, and that guilt says a lot about the episode as a whole, and also about Larry as an individual. For as long as we can remember, he’s always existed on the fringe as an outsider of popular opinion, and one might argue Rick’s situation spoke to him. Or, maybe this is all bullshit and just a great premise. You make the call.
— Michael Roffman
16. “The Survivor” from Season 4, Episode 9
Premiere Date: March 7, 2004
Are You Crazy? While much of Season 4 — and “The Survivor” — is focused on Larry’s 10th anniversary present, Cheryl receives hers, the renewal of their vows. But of course, Larry doesn’t make it easy on her, offending both her parents and the temple’s rabbi who is to lead the service along the way.
“Get the Fuck Outta My House, Larry!” While Susie doesn’t play a big part in “The Survivor,” she makes one hilarious appearance. When Larry comes to Jeff to ask about Anna, the Hasidic employee at his cleaners and his best chance to capitalize on his 10th anniversary gift, she butts in: “They cut a hole in the sheet, the man puts the penis in; they can’t touch each other Larry. What do you guys talk about? This is what you talk about, how Hasidim have sex?”
Vanilla Bullshit Things: We’ve got a tie here, between Larry’s problem with the rabbi’s sensitivity to his son’s death on 9/11 and his mother-in-law’s refusal to get a sponge after the Holocaust survivor spilled gravy on his suit. When Larry exclaims, “Let’s roll,” a common saying that became a national slogan following the terrorist attacks, offends the rabbi, whose son was killed by a bike messenger on 57th Street in Manhattan, miles away from the World Trade Centers. On the other hand, Larry’s mother-in-law almost skips out on his vow renewal ceremony because she was so angry at him for his response to her “someone get a sponge!” comment. Let’s call this one a draw.
He’s Not My Best Friend! When preparing their vows prior to their renewal ceremony, Cheryl reveals that she intends for their marriage to continue after death through all eternity. Of course, Larry, who has always heard “til death do us part,” objects — “I guess I had a different plan for eternity. I thought I’d be single.” He later stumbles during his vows in the ceremony, even asking the rabbi if an afterlife exists, proving once again that Larry always will never truly see eye to eye with Cheryl (or any woman).
Stop and Chat: “You know, Shlomo is at shul. Want to come in for a drink?” says Gina Gershon in her most seductive voice. Playing the Hasidic dry cleaner, the Pretty in Pink and Face/Off actress gives Larry one of his best and last chances at capitalizing on his 10th anniversary gift. In the end, Susie and Jeff’s hole in the sheet idea is a myth and Larry blows it at the last second. “Did you come here to fuck or did you come here to talk about your dirty suit?” she grumbles after Larry has let her down one last time.
Socially Assassinated: The loser of “The Survivor” has to be Solly, the Holocaust survivor, who was utterly embarrassed twice in this episode, first following his Holocaust vs. Survivor debate with Colby Donaldson and later when Larry was almost blinded by his glass eye. He went down fighting, however, spilling on Larry twice, having the last laugh when Larry had to go through his vow renewals with a massive wine stain on his suit.
Episode as a GIF:
Get In That Ass: “May I always have the wisdom to look past your shortcomings and appreciate all of the goodness you possess,” begins Cheryl’s vow to Larry, basically summing up their entire marriage. Almost a full four seasons into the show, we’re more than familiar with Larry’s shortcomings and his inability to stay out of unnecessary awkward and cringeworthy situations. “Marriage is punishment for shoplifting in some countries,” goes a Wayne’s World one-liner. If that’s the case, marriage to Larry David may be punishment for much, much worse.
Pretty, Pretty, Pretty Good: In early 2004, Survivor was still incredibly popular — America was still very much in its reality TV phase. Colby Donaldson, the second place winner in the second season, was very much a celebrity at the time, which is why the (Holocaust) survivor vs. Survivor scene is so amazing, an all-time best dialogue. Comparing the conditions between the Holocaust and Survivor: The Australian Outback, is absurd, but set up in an incredibly clever way as Larry thinks that both were survivors of the worst genocide in history — “Do survivors like seeing each other and talking about old times?”
It may not be the best episode in the fourth season — that honor goes to finale “Opening Night” — but from the survivor face-off to Larry’s inability to rebound after thinking Hasidic couples have sex with a sheet, it’s one of the best in Curb’s catalogue.
— Steven Edelstone
15. “The Black Swan” from Season 7, Episode 7
Premiere Date: November 1, 2009
Are You Crazy? Away from the hustle and bustle of the Seinfeld reunion, Larry tries to find some peace at his ritzy golf club alongside his crew, only to unconsciously spawn a murder-spree, one that starts with a little involuntary manslaughter (inciting Norm’s heart attack) and peaks with one hell of a self defense move (bludgeoning Mr. Tagahashi’s prized black swan). As per tradition, Larry’s seemingly at the disposal of his own surroundings, though to be fair, most of his qualms stem from an unnerving lack of respect. This is LD in full-on mafioso mode, refusing to silence his cell phone, protesting math, and snubbing the dead, whether it’s shrugging over a prick like Norm or a celebrated mascot like Kyoko. He hates everyone here.
“Get the Fuck Outta My House, Larry!” Susie’s never been one to golf, so she’s not exactly ordering crispy onions alongside Andy. However, she does come up when Mr. Tagahashi grills Larry’s crew over Kyoko’s death. As he moves from one friend to the other — specifically, Andy, Marty, Jeff, and Larry in that order — Tagahasi tells Jeff he’s “stupid” for marrying a “big-mouth wife,” saying he should call her, to which Jeff protests and hilariously adds, “I don’t even bring her around anymore out of respect.” Ah, poor Susie.
Vanilla Bullshit Things: “It’s a pointless and unnecessary social convention to introduce every single person you know,” Larry tells The Funkman (Bob Einstein), after Marty expresses disappointment that Larry didn’t introduce everyone at the table to his passing New York acquaintance. Of course, by the end, this system winds up screwing Larry over in a big way when Marty neglects to introduce the stonemason, letting his bald friend go to town on the Derek Jeter-hating son of a bitch unknowingly in his presence. Larry 0, Funkman 1.
He’s Not My Best Friend! While not exactly broken up, out of all the members in Larry’s gang, it’s Marty who’s the most temperate when it comes to Norm’s death, immediately laying blame on Larry: “Look, it may have been an accident… but you’re a murderer.” He later has trouble eating following Kyoko’s death and even expresses interest in outing Larry for Tagahashi’s offer of no monthly membership fees. He doesn’t — after all, let’s not forget, Larry’s his “best friend” — but the fact that it crosses his mind says everything you need to know about their relationship. Also, his contempt for Andy and his (deadly) crispy onions is Peak Funkman, especially the delivery of this line: “Will you please finish shoveling that shit into your face?” Great.
Stop and Chat: Given that the season is overstuffed with big guest stars, “The Black Swan” is something of a reprieve. Though, if there was ever a time to hate Andy, it’s this one. Returning star Richard Kind has made a career out of being a lovable lug, always bordering on the insufferable, and he brings his A-game to this episode, riding on Larry’s nerves in ways that are unprecedented.
We’ve already talked about his godforsaken crispy onions, the likes of which make them late to the green and stuck behind Norm’s painfully slow crew, but then there’s his embarrassing disappointment over fruit plates, his wife’s tacky hats, and their complete lack of respect over Larry’s offer to pay for their daughter’s college tuition. When Andy later revisits the kind gesture, asking Larry to put his wife through cosmetology school instead, you kind of want to burn those hats along with Larry.
Socially Assassinated: Well, there’s Norm, who actually gets assassinated, even if Larry didn’t intend for him to keel over. Then there’s the tragedy of Kyoko, that lovable black swan that may or may not have actually scared Norm, per Larry’s theory. But then there’s also Larry, whose self-righteous don act can’t stop him from tripping over his own systems, as he later discovers that the aforementioned Jeter-hating stonemason has etched his deep, dark secret on stone for all to see. Yes, he’s a swan killer, and no, he can’t bullshit his way out of this one.
Episode as a GIF:
Get In That Ass: “Let me explain something to you, moron. Swan killers leave. People who aren’t swan killers stay, have a little lunch, enjoy themselves, socialize, get to know the members.” It’s maybe not the most pleasant advice, per se, but if you’re ever on the lam, never hesitate to call Larry David. His choice words to the Funkman, who’s overwhelmed with guilt and anxiety, are awash with the type of logic that’ll keep anyone out of prison.
Pretty, Pretty, Pretty Good: It’s essentially Curb gone mafioso. Much like later seasons of Seinfeld, “The Black Swan” exists in a heightened version of reality than we’re traditionally used to on the series. But that’s fine because, again like Seinfeld, these characters are larger-than-life enough to be able to try on new suits without anyone batting an eye. In Larry’s case, we know he has a vicious mean streak, so seeing him embellish that attitude only makes sense as the through-line becomes more and more extravagant.
That extravagance, however, speaks volumes for a season that revolves around the Seinfeld reunion, as if David’s making a spiritual nod to those last two years the NBC series trucked on without him, an era that brought similar out-of-this-world fare like “The Chicken Roaster,” “The Muffin Tops,” and “The Merv Griffin Show.” In other words, crazy works for Curb, too.
— Michael Roffman
14. “Mister Softee” from Season 8, Episode 9
Premiere Date: September 4, 2011
Are You Crazy? For 99.999% of New Yorkers, the Mister Softee song invokes pleasant memories of bygone summers, sprinting to the street on a hot day to get a soft-serve ice cream to cool down. But of course, Larry has to be contrarian; the ice cream truck’s jingle brings him back to his childhood when he lost to a middle school crush in strip poker inside a Mister Softee truck only to be pushed outside by the driver — her father — completely naked in front of a dozen onlookers screaming, “What the fuck?!” and laughing at the size of his penis.
Still traumatized some 50 or so years later, the jingle continues to haunt Larry, causing him to perform poorly in bed with his girlfriend and lose his softball championship by pulling a Bill Buckner and misplaying a routine groundball through his legs only to watch the winning run score from third. But by working with a therapist who has no clue how to keep a secret, he attempts to confront one of his more painful memories, but almost loses his girlfriend to another “man” — his car.
“Get the Fuck Outta My House, Larry!” For Jeff’s birthday, Susie tells Larry to get him a signed Mookie Wilson baseball and while at the event, Larry unsurprisingly befriends Bill Buckner, whose error cost the Red Sox their first World Series in almost 70 years. The two visit Jeff and Susie at their apartment, but they lose the ball out the window when Larry tosses it to Buckner who can’t make the catch. “I thought you were a professional, you couldn’t even catch?” Susie screams as she kicks them out. “I thought you were a baseball player — you can’t catch a god damn toss?”
Vanilla Bullshit Things: “Do you like a mixed nut?” Larry asks his girlfriend Jennifer as she is having a heavy orgasm due to the loose seat in his car’s passenger seat, causing for an incredibly bumpy and satisfying ride. “When I opened up the mixed nuts, they put some dried pineapple! Are you kidding me with the pineapple? The dried pineapple is destroying the mixed nuts!” Larry complains while blissfully unaware of what’s transpiring a foot to his right. This marks the second time in Curb where Larry complains about mixed nuts, a callback to season four when he started a fight with David Schwimmer’s father, the owner of a trail mix company, about the ratio of cashews to raisins in his packages.
He’s Not My Best Friend! How many times have you decided to split an entrée with a friend at a restaurant and it actually worked out? Larry finds out the hard way at the beginning of the episode, as Jeff decides not to share. “That fish, to be honest, don’t look so good,” Jeff says before nearly begging Larry for a bite when he raves about how fantastic his meal is.
Stop and Chat: While Bill Buckner is the most instrumental guest star for this episode’s plot, legendary SNL writer and Triumph the Insult Comic Dog owner Robert Smigel steals the show as Larry’s George Steinbrenner-obsessed softball manager and car mechanic. “Fuck these people!” he screams in his pregame speech after yelling about having sex with the opposing team’s sisters. After Larry “Buckners” the game, he refuses to fix Larry’s car, which leads to the bumpy passenger seat. As an aside, pre-fame Amy Schumer makes a five second or so appearance in the episode as Larry’s teammate, shouting, “You’re a douche,” after he loses them the championship.
Socially Assassinated: In Judaism, a minyan — a quorum of 10 Jews — is sometimes required for specific traditions, in this case, to perform a “Mourners’ Kaddish,” a prayer for the recently deceased. When walking Park Avenue with Bill Buckner, Larry is approached to join the group so the obligation can be completed for the dead relative. It turns out that the family are die-hard Red Sox fans and while Buckner is kicked out because his error in 1986. Larry also leaves, denying the mourning family the chance to perform the prayer for their dead relative. “I hope there is no afterlife!” Larry proclaims as he walks out the door.
Episode as a GIF:
Get In That Ass: “She’s cheating on you with this fucking chair!” Leon exclaims as he realizes Larry’s dilemma with his girlfriend, though probably not realizing his statement’s double meaning. Now knowledgeable that his passenger seat is “the other man,” Larry runs into a lot of trouble when he has to give Susie an impromptu ride, leading to one of the most awkward and memorable scenes in the history of Curb.
Pretty, Pretty, Pretty Good: Of all of the episodes in season eight, “Mister Softee” is Curb’s most quintessentially New York show, all centered around what could be the city’s most iconic songs after taking Frank Sinatra and LCD Soundsystem out of the equation. “Mister Softee” includes references to the famed ice cream truck jingle, softball in Central Park, the ’86 Mets, and more, finally giving his fans the true New York episode we deserved, especially when realizing that Seinfeld was shot in LA.
The most surprising thing here isn’t that George Lucas enjoys the services of prostitutes, it’s the intense hatred of Bill Buckner, who gave the Mets their only title since 1969. He should be a hero in New York rather than the villain, but by the end of the episode, he finally gets his dues as he saves a baby after a multi-story fall from a burning building.
— Steven Edelstone