Advertisement

Ranking: Every Mastodon Album from Worst to Best

The modern metal masters have put together an impressive discography

mastodon albums ranked
Mastodon (photo by Clay Patrick McBride)
Advertisement
Advertisement

    Welcome to Dissected, where we disassemble a band’s catalog, a director’s filmography, or some other critical pop-culture collection. It’s exact science by way of a few beers. This time, we follow Mastodon’s impressive career, from their 2002 debut, Remission, to their most recent effort, 2021’s Hushed and Grim.

    Atlanta quartet Mastodon have spent 20-plus years as one of the most daring, dexterous, and delightfully badass metal bands of the new millennium. That’s no small feat considering how many forward-thinking acts are out there. However, it’s hard to disagree given the foursome’s unparalleled knack for channeling influences like Iron Maiden, Neurosis, Pink Floyd, and King Crimson into wholly characteristic concoctions of vibrant sludge/stoner/progressive metal madness.

    From the beginning — with 2002’s savage Remission and 2004’s more sophisticated Leviathan, the group — comprised of singer-bassist Troy Sanders, singer-guitarist Brent Hinds, singer-drummer Brann Dailor, and guitarist Bill Kelliher — showcased a singular ability to fuse thunderous temperaments with remarkable melodic flair and toweringly epic scopes. Of course, 2006’s Blood Mountain followed, offering a superbly colorful, elaborate, and zany full realization of that recipe.

    Advertisement

    Afterward, 2009’s comparatively spacey and accessible Crack the Skye emphasized the band’s 1970s prog rock influences. Then, 2011’s The Hunter and 2014’s Once More ‘Round the Sun basically acted as hodgepodges of their predecessors’ standout proclivities. 2017’s Emperor of Sand saw the palpable return of Crack the Skye producer Brendan O’Brien, while 2021’s Hushed and Grim expectedly provided the troupe’s most mature and extensive collection so far.

    Along the way, they’ve had several LPs peak highly on the Billboard 200. They’ve also been nominated for many prestigious awards (earning a Grammy win in 2017 for Best Metal Performance), and featured in numerous video games (including Tony Hawk’s Underground and Guitar Hero III), movies (such as Monsters University and Bill & Ted Face the Music), and TV (Game of Thrones).

    While there really is no weak Mastodon album, some are simply more special than others. With the band set to kick off its co-headlining US tour with Opeth (tickets available here), we’ve penned this definitive rating of their eight studio albums. Hunt down our ranking below.

    –Jordan Blum,
    Contributing Writer


    Advertisement

    8. The Hunter (2011)

    mbid 65365fe7 91a4 4e3e a589 d62c80789525 24721146918 Ranking: Every Mastodon Album from Worst to Best

    Megalodown (Analysis): When Mastodon set to work on 2011’s The Hunter, they were four albums into their career and batting 1.000. Expectations were reasonably high. To follow up 2009’s Crack the Skye — their most ambitious and commercially successful effort to date — was no small order. Would the band go full prog, expanding on lengthy excursions like “The Czar”?

    Maybe Mastodon needed a breather from the intensity of their own material. The Hunter almost sounds like a different band: an attempt at writing a straight-ahead heavy rock album. There’s an emphasis on pop song structures and melodies, and the band hoist a stoner-rock sound akin to Queens of the Stone Age. The sludge and stoner metal scenes ran parallel and often overlapped around the turn of the decade in 2010; the transition in style wasn’t too surprising or outlandish.

    Advertisement

    Yet, fans got the sense that Mastodon were pumping the brakes and easing off the more complex blend of prog-psych riff mastery that defined their first four albums. Three LPs into their major label partnership with Reprise, the band were settling into a more mature, mainstream sound. Who could blame the band for wanting to craft a more consumable product to the masses? They’d already carved three masterpieces, and one thing’s for certain — The Hunter isn’t redundant. Even if it’s their weakest full-length, it exemplified a band taking a brave career leap, naturally evolving and refusing to recycle its own ideas.

    Quintessence (Best Song): Opener and lead single “Black Tongue” got the hype rolling for The Hunter. The track hints at the more accessible rock direction the band were moving toward, but it still brought the heaviness of past records. The rest of the album fails to live up to it, perhaps another reason the LP received a lukewarm reception from eager fans. “Black Tongue” got us too stoked, and unfortunately, there wasn’t more where that came from. The album peaked with its first song and single.

    Advertisement

    Tread Lightly (Worst Song): If The Hunter’s stock peaked when “Black Tongue” was unveiled, the disappointing follow-up single “Curl of the Burl” let the wind out of the sails. The hammed-up lyrics and an overt QotSA vibe came out of leftfield, beckoning suspicious fans to inevitably toss around tired accusations of Mastodon “selling out.” The band wanting to make a more accessible record isn’t the problem; it’s that the song is simply not very good. The Hunter turned out to be more like “Curl” than “Black Tongue.” — Jon Hadusek

    Pick up The Hunter here.


    7. Remission (2002)

    mbid 446c0f67 d625 41a2 a7ce ff139a367d7b 29843354237 Ranking: Every Mastodon Album from Worst to Best

    Megalodown: Raw and inspired, Mastodon’s debut full-length Remission introduced the Georgia quartet with 11 uncompromising blasters. Drummer Brann Dailor and guitarist Bill Kelliher brought technical metal and metalcore influences from prior acts and the virtuosic musical wizardry those genres required. Meanwhile, bassist Troy Sanders and guitarist Brent Hinds added a gruffy Southern-sludge vocal approach. Mythological and literary lyrical themes elevated the compositions with undeniably metal imagery.

    When storied metal label Relapse introduced Mastodon and Remission, the beacons were lit and the scene responded. In the age of millennial nu-metal and post-grunge, metal needed a new flag bearer; something more artistically substantial that could elevate the genre spiritually and intellectually.

    Advertisement

    Mastodon were that band, and Remission was the sound of the war horn — a call to arms in the battle against the rising hordes of false metal. Mastodon would sharpen and hone their sound on future albums, but this humble debut maintains an historical relevance that makes it required listening for anyone interested in the development of modern metal.

    Quintessence: “Trilobite” is the standout track. Carrying a beautiful atmosphere and more melodic sound, it is the most indicative of what Mastodon were capable of in the recording studio. The longer track length offers a bit more space for slower tempos and more dynamic range; the band had those prog inclinations from the beginning.

    Advertisement

    Tread Lightly: “Trampled Under Hoof” is an example of the technical metalcore influence that was still present in Mastodon’s sound at this time. The arrangement is claustrophobic and the verses collapse on themselves with choppy time-signatures and rhythmic fissures. It’s proficiently played, but deliberately difficult and somewhat aimless. Mastodon could have been a math band, but they would rein in the complexity on future releases … for the better. — Jon Hadusek

    Pick up Remission here.


    6. Emperor of Sand (2017)

    mbid bbb156cf cd21 4d45 8c35 f53c1f6605bd 29843521495 Ranking: Every Mastodon Album from Worst to Best

    Megalodown: After developing their conceptual and compositional expertise with their first four works, the foursome went down a looser and livelier route on 2011’s The Hunter and 2014’s Once More ‘Round the Sun. While still entertaining and praiseworthy, the duo were more polarizing than their forebearers. Therefore, it’s no shock that the group re-teamed with Crack the Skye producer Brendan O’Brien to create the guaranteed-not-to-fail Emperor of Sand. Easily their safest venture, it’s an extremely engaging and representative sequence that simply doesn’t take enough risks — good or bad — to feel notable.

    What is notable is that it’s their first LP to earn a Grammy nod for Best Rock Album. Although it lost to The War on Drugs’ A Deeper Understanding, its opening song — “Sultan’s Curse” — earned the band its first Grammy for Best Metal Performance. As for its prevailing topic — mortality — its tale of a desert wanderer being “handed a death sentence” by the namesake monarch was inspired by the band’s multiple encounters with cancer.

    Advertisement

    Emperor of Sand sounds great — with marvelous touches from O’Brien — and flows well. It’s also full of irresistible hooks (“Show Yourself,” “Steambreather,” “Roots Remain”) and intricately erratic musicianship (“Word to the Wise,” “Andromeda”). That said, its relative lack of daringness and variety results in a somewhat unexciting experience. It’d be much more amazing if we hadn’t essentially heard it six times before.

    Quintessence: It’s probably an unpopular opinion, but “Precious Stones” strikes the sharpest balance between compelling melodies and incredible instrumentation. Hinds’ leading Southern drawl is as pleasing as ever, and the group’s harmonies are quite tight. All the while, the first two minutes foster tempting anticipation for what’s undisputedly the greatest guitar lick on Emperor of Sand. It’s the totally sublime cornerstone of the composition, and it ingeniously dictates how the rest of it ebbs and flows.

    Advertisement

    Tread Lightly: “Scorpion Breath” is exceedingly loud and aggressive, but it fails to stand out among the rest of the album’s tracks. Even with the addition of frequent collaborator Scott Kelly (Neurosis) — plus some nice acoustic arpeggios and startling tempo changes — it’s serviceable at best. Admirers of Mastodon’s markedly bestial early period likely adore it, but for the rest of us, there’s not enough to latch onto. Honestly, it merely takes up space before things get back on track with “Jaguar God.” — Jordan Blum

    Pick up Emperor of Sand here.


    5. Once More ‘Round the Sun (2014)

    mbid 1384f9d6 9136 457b a347 8e9f819264a5 29843370532 Ranking: Every Mastodon Album from Worst to Best

    Megalodown: Following the tame reception toward The Hunter, the band offered up the best of both worlds with 2014’s Once More ‘Round the Sun. Everything Mastodon threw at their previous LP — the pop hooks, the stoner rock tropes — is better applied here. They’d found the ideal blend between the early-era prog/sludge and the modern heavy rock sound.

    At this point, Mastodon had also mastered the triple-vocal versatility of Sanders, Hinds, and Dailor. Each brings their own distinct and recognizable timbre, and producer Nick Raskulinecz managed to balance the trio perfectly across 54 minutes — three singers for the price of one. It’s one of Mastodon’s greatest assets and makes Once More ‘Round the Sun arguably the group’s most playful full-length. Each track sounds fresh and varied, while the vocal hooks are as memorable as the riffs.

    Advertisement

    Quintessence: Kicking off with an alluring guitar line, the six-minute opus “Asleep in the Deep” bolsters the middle of the tracklist. A dreamy arrangement of melodic vocals and Voivod-esque prog workouts create a psych soundscape, among the prettiest in Mastodon’s catalog. This was art rock that was missing from The Hunter. It’s gorgeous stuff.

    Tread Lightly: “Aunt Lisa” kicks off with a stellar, winding opening riff. But the track gets disqualified for its bizarre, awkward ending featuring a gang chorus of cheerleaders chanting: “Hey, ho, let’s f**king go!” As previously stated, this is Mastodon at their most playful… maybe too playful in this instance. — Jon Hadusek

    Advertisement

    Pick up Once More ‘Round the Sun here.


Personalized Stories

Around The Web

Advertisement